| Are hackers using your PC to spew spam and
steal?
By Byron Acohido and Jon Swartz, USA TODAY
Betty Carty figured she ought to be in the
digital fast lane.
Last Christmas, Carty purchased a Dell desktop
computer, then signed up for a Comcast high-speed Internet
connection. But her new Windows XP machine crashed frequently and
would only plod across the Internet.
Dell was no help. The PC maker insisted —
correctly — that Carty's hardware worked fine.
But in June, Comcast curtailed Carty's outbound
e-mail privileges after pinpointing her PC as a major source of
e-mail spam. An intruder had turned Carty's PC into a "zombie,"
spreading as many as 70,000 pieces of e-mail spam a day.
The soft-spoken Carty, 54, a grandmother of
three from southern New Jersey, was flabbergasted. "Someone had
broken into my computer," she says.
Since early 2003, wave after wave of infectious
programs have begun to saturate the Internet, causing the number of
PCs hijacked by hackers and turned into so-called zombies to soar
into the millions — mostly in homes like Carty's, at small
businesses and on college campuses. And, much like zombies of voodoo
legend, they mindlessly do the bidding of their masters and help
commit crimes online.
Personal computers have never been more
powerful — and dangerous. Just as millions of Americans are buying
new PCs and signing up for ultrafast Internet connections,
cybercrooks are stepping up schemes to take control of their
machines — and most consumers don't have a clue.
"We thought things were bad in 2003, but we've
seen a sharp uptick in 2004. I'm worried things will get much
worse," says Ed Skoudis, co-founder of consulting firm
Intelguardians
Carty's PC could have been taken over in myriad
ways. She could have been fooled into opening a virus-infected
e-mail. She might have innocently surfed to a Web page bristling
with contagious code. Or she may have done nothing at all. One of
dozens of network worms, voracious, self-replicating programs that
pinball around the Web searching for security holes in Windows PCs,
may have found one on her new PC.
Profitable attacks
Cyberintrusions traditionally have been the
domain of socially inept males launching electronic attacks for fun
and bragging rights, often creating a huge, if transient, nuisance
for companies and consumers. But things are changing: More PCs are
being taken over purely for profit.
Over the past eight months, USA TODAY
interviewed more than 100 tech-industry executives, consultants,
analysts, regulators and security experts who say top-tier code
writers now create malicious programs mainly to amass networks of
zombie PCs. They then sell access to zombie networks to spammers,
blackmailers and identity thieves who orchestrate fraudulent
for-profit schemes.
Most consumers are slow to grasp that an
intruder has usurped control of their PC. "We have a large
population that is easily tricked," says Dave Dittrich, senior
security engineer at the University of Washington's Center for
Information Assurance and Cybersecurity.
One measure of the swelling tide of zombie PCs:
E-mail spam continues to skyrocket, with zombies driving the
increase. In July, spam made up 94.5% of e-mail traffic, nearly
double from a year before, says e-mail management firm MessageLabs.
Postini, another big e-mail handler, estimates nearly 40% of spam
now comes from zombie networks.
Using zombies to broadcast spam for Viagra or
quickie loans has emerged as a huge business. Yet spreading ordinary
spam is actually one of a compromised computer's more benign tasks.
Bigger spoils lie in using zombies in elaborate phishing scams, in
which e-mail directs consumers to bogus Web pages to trick them into
surrendering personal information.
And zombie networks are perfectly suited to
flood targeted Web sites with data requests, in so-called
distributed denial-of-service, or DDoS, attacks. Cybercrooks use the
threat of a DDoS attack to extort protection money from businesses
keen to keep their Web sites running.
Few laws, few arrests
Until recently, little has been done to stop
such attacks. The Justice Department's Operation Web Snare netted
160 arrests in August that could lead to more busts, offering
encouraging news to cybersecurity experts who have criticized law
enforcement for not doing enough. Still, detractors point out there
are few federal cybersecurity laws with stiff penalties.
Federal, state and local law enforcement
officials face daunting jurisdictional hurdles trying to corner,
much less extradite, suspects. Chasing bad guys equipped to commit
virtual crimes in several countries simultaneously has proved
problematic, as has the sheer volume of incidents.
"It's easier trying to catch Osama bin Laden,"
says Steve Jillings, CEO of e-mail security firm FrontBridge
Technologies.
Zombie victim Carty took matters into her own
hands: She did research on how to clean up and protect her PC and
diligently updates programs that scan her computer for various types
of malicious code. Her PC now runs clean. "I had no clue at
Christmas that I would become a security expert," she says.
Consumers remain seduced by the Internet's
convenience. E-commerce is bigger than ever, and most casual
computer users overlook safety practices. The vast majority don't
use firewall software to block intruders, patch vulnerabilities or
keep anti-virus subscriptions current.
"Consumers seem almost bizarrely unconcerned by
security in general," says James Governor, founder of research firm
RedMonk. "People will practically give out their Social Security
number as easily as their phone number."
Low and slow thievery
Heather Hall can trace the start of her online
banking nightmare to the day she received what she thought was a
legitimate e-mail request from Bank of America asking her to click a
link to a bank Web page. The 27-year-old health services worker
typed in her login, password and account number.
Not long afterward, Hall noticed an
unauthorized withdrawal on her banking statement for $6.50. The
withdrawals increased in frequency and amounts, to as much as $108.
Hall was the victim of a "low and slow" phishing scam, in which
cybercriminals purposely steal small amounts of cash — sometimes as
little as 20 cents at a time — to avoid detection.
Though data are scarce, experts estimate
millions of dollars are being skimmed from thousands of online
banking accounts. About 23.6 million people had online accounts at
the nation's top 10 banks in the second quarter of 2004, up 28% from
the year before, says ComScore Networks.
Sneaky cybercrooks are finding it profitable to
"be patient and nick an account for a long time," says Dan Larkin,
unit chief of the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center.
Bank of America agreed to reimburse the money
stolen from Hall's account, but only after she badgered them. "They
wanted me to believe it was my fault," says Hall.
Bank of America does not comment on specific
cases. It reimburses victims of fraud and changes their online name
and password, spokeswoman Betty Riess says.
First seen more than a year ago, phishing scams
begin with e-mail messages broadcast to potential victims. The
e-mail directs them, often under the guise of doing a security
check, to a bogus Web page with the identical look and feel of an
authentic page.
A network of zombie PCs e-mails the original
request to tens of thousands of potential dupes. A separate zombie,
usually a more powerful PC, often sitting in a remote country,
perhaps in an obscure nook at a university, serves up the
counterfeit Web page. Another zombie, in yet another country,
perhaps in the basement of a small shop, stores the stolen account
details and conducts the theft.
"Computer networks make this easy to do since
they form a virtual world in which footprints and fingerprints are
easily erased at a distance," says the University of Washington's
Dittrich.
Experts say clues point to loosely organized
crime syndicates, probably in Russia, Latvia, Kazakhstan and China,
coordinating phishing scams with other schemes to quickly turn
stolen account information into tangible booty. In what feds call
one of the biggest phishing busts, a Romanian man was arrested last
year and convicted for using an elaborate network of bogus Web pages
and escrow accounts to fleece Americans out of $500,000.
Typically, filched financial information, such
as credit card numbers, is sold on Web sites. Buyers often use card
numbers to make long-distance phone calls, sign up for pornographic
sites and buy computers over the Internet.
Unique phishing attacks have surged more than
10 times since January, to 1,974 in July, and show no sign of
slowing. In early August, MessageLabs intercepted more than 125,000
phishing e-mails containing links to a replica of a well-known U.S.
bank's Web site within the first five hours of its appearance.
U.S. banks are in a delicate position. Their
customers lost an estimated $2.4 billion from phishing in the 12
months ending in April, according to market researcher Gartner.
Citibank, a frequent target, warned users of a dozen examples of
phishing solicitations on its Web sites in the first half of
June.
Few, however, are willing to discuss such
matters in detail out of fear of scaring customers and undercutting
trust in online banking, in which they've invested hundreds of
millions of dollars, says John Pironti, a security consultant at
Unisys.
Now, free, do-it-yourself phishing kits are
surfacing on the Internet. Would-be cybercrooks can choose from a
dozen kits containing bogus Web sites, programming code and spam
tailored toward customers of Citibank, eBay and PayPal, says analyst
Chris Kraft of security firm Sophos.
The same zombie network used in phishing scams
can also bombard a Web site with data requests. When that happens,
no one else can get to the targeted Web site, effectively shutting
it down.
Such an assault is known as a distributed
denial-of-service, or DDoS, attack. Cybercrooks threaten DDoS
attacks just as racketeers wave truncheons. Last January, a series
of such attacks began against major Internet gambling operators in
the United Kingdom. The attacks were preceded with e-mail messages
demanding $10,000 to $40,000.
Some operators paid — and were immediately
attacked again, according to a report from the Association of Remote
Gambling Operators. The blackmail attempts continue.
LadbrokesCasino.com, one of the UK's largest online gambling Web
sites, recently reported coming under attack from 518,000 zombie
computers.
New methods of attack
Seattle screenwriter Alex Tobias figured her
laptop was immune to attacks. After all, she and her husband,
Martin, a venture capitalist, worked from home a lot. To protect
their home network, Martin installed top-notch firewall and
anti-virus software.
Yet last fall, Alex's laptop slowed until she
couldn't use e-mail or the Internet. It took extensive
troubleshooting to determine that it had been turned into a
spam-spreading zombie, and it took half a day to clean it up. "I
don't know what she got or how she got it," says Martin. "The bottom
line is she got it."
Their experience underscores the notion that
there are many ways for malicious code to slip past firewalls and
anti-virus programs. E-mail viruses, for instance, rely on tricking
the victim into opening an infectious attachment. Another widely
used tool is harder to fight: direct planting of contagions, known
as "come-and-get-it" viruses, on popular Web sites.
Such contagions commonly lurk on peer-to-peer
sites, where music and movies are exchanged. They trick the computer
user into giving up personal information, and they can activate
other invasive programs unseen by the PC owner.
Web contagions are turning up on high-traffic
Web pages across the Internet. Most do the basics: plant a back-door
Trojan horse and turn over full control to an intruder who might be
sitting half a globe away.
Some have begun implanting spyware called
keystroke loggers, which are designed to notice whenever the PC user
types anything that looks like account information. It grabs the
information and sends it to a zombie computer for storage and
risk-free access by the crooks.
The scariest type of attack is one most
consumers aren't aware of. Scores of sophisticated programs, called
worms and bots, continually scour the Internet for Windows PCs with
security holes. There are hundreds of Windows vulnerabilities, and
new ones turn up regularly. Microsoft issues software patches, or
fixes, each month for the most troublesome. But most home users, and
many businesses, don't keep up to date on patches.
Consumer outrage needed
Not long ago, securing the Internet meant
cleaning up after so-called script kiddies, youths who use
pre-written malicious code, available free on the Web, to pull
digital pranks. But security has metastasized into an almost
fatalistic endeavor. "Hackers can do almost anything with a
compromised PC, and there isn't much we can do about it," says Keith
Lourdeau, deputy assistant director of the FBI's Cyber Division.
That will change only as tech suppliers who
profit from the Internet simplify networks and collaborate on
implementing universal security standards that may run counter to
their current business strategies. Many experts say such a shift is
at least five years away. The one thing that could make tech
suppliers move more quickly is consumer outrage.
"Consumers should demand what they do of other
utilities," says Kip McClanahan, CEO of security firm Tipping Point.
"When I pay my water bill, I expect my water to be drinkable out of
the tap. Today, when you pay your Internet bill, the data you get is
not consumable."
Tomorrow: The tech industry begins to fight
back
|